Something weird about her makeup

蔣家旻Angel: She's very pretty, but her makeup makes her look funny.
Is it the dark circles under her eyes or the yellow teeth?
Maybe the bluish-purple eye shadow doesn't match with the glossy lip color?
Maybe because the foundation is shades lighter than her natural skin tone?

She looks just like me in terms of how I apply my makeup.
How can I achieve a more natural look without seeming ridiculous?

Her makeup here looks more natural here.
Maybe because the photo is less focused in this one.

Here's another closed up of another girl.
The eyelashes look so ridiculous up closed.
So maybe all the nice photos we've been seeing in magazines and the internet are actually touched ups.
Up closed and in real life, they all look too "make up."